Case StudyGeneral Manufacturing
Mac Lellan

Maclellan Integrated Services

Robotic Weld Lines Cleaned Safely With Less Labor and Lower Costs

3 min read

TL;DR

Weld slag, spatter, and oil build-up on robotic welding jigs caused proximity-switch misfires, scrap, and equipment failure, and traditional hammer-and-chisel cleaning risked damaging the equipment. Maclellan Integrated Services switched to Cold Jet dry ice cleaning and cut labor by up to 69%, cut cleaning costs by up to 60%, and eliminated chemical solvents and secondary waste.

The Challenge

Weld Slag Buildup Caused Misfires, Scrap, and Downtime

Weld slag, spatter, resin, smoke, oil, and dampering adhesive build up on production equipment. This causes misalignment and can prevent the proximity switch from firing in the appropriate spot. The robot stops welding – or welds incorrectly – creating scrap and causing equipment failure and production downtime.

Traditional cleaning methods to remove weld spatter and slag from welding jigs, cells and robots – such as using a hammer and chisel – can damage the weld line equipment and ultimately lead to increased downtime.

robotic automotive weld line cleaning with dry ice blasting
The Solution

Cold Jet Dry Ice Cleaning Replaces Hammer-and-Chisel Maintenance

Cold Jet dry ice cleaning systems provide an effective, economical and delicate removal solution for slag and spatter build up. Cold Jet’s dry ice cleaning systems use non-abrasive media in the form of recycled CO2 pellets that won’t damage surfaces. The combination of dry ice cleaning’s kinetic energy and thermal effects break the connection between the dirt and surface, lifting away contaminants. Unlike blasting with other media, dry ice cleaning does not leave behind any secondary waste, because the dry ice particles sublimate on impact – converting from a solid to a gas. Dry ice cleaning is safe and nontoxic, does not create downstream contamination and reduces exposure to dangerous chemical cleaning agents.

“

We are able to do 2-3 times the number of jobs with dry ice cleaning and the outcome is better. We can also meet the kaizen ‘shared cost reduction’ now using dry ice blasting and still make good margins on the job. Lastly, we keep finding more applications for dry ice blasting, ultimately creating additional business for us with the same customer.

”
— Steve Foster, Plant Operations Manager
The Results

Fewer Workers, Less Time, Lower Cost, Safer Process

ROI in 2.3 months

69%

Labor Reduction

Labor time reduced vs. traditional hammer-and-chisel cleaning

60%

Cost Reduction

Cleaning cost reduced vs. traditional methods

$153,712

Annual Savings

Estimated annual savings across 38 robot cleanings per week

2.3 Months

to reach roi

Equivalent to 344 robot cleanings

Using Cold Jet’s Aero 40 single-hose dry ice cleaning system resulted in the following benefits when compared to hammering and chiseling:

  • Reduced required labor from 4 workers to 1.
  • Reduced labor time by up to 69%.
  • Reduced cleaning costs by up to 60%.
  • Drastically reduced equipment damage (though photoeyes and proximity sensors should not be deliberately or directly blasted).
  • Dramatically decreased labor intensity because it is safer and more ergonomic for the worker, thus improving overall worker morale.
  • Eliminated the use of chemical solvents, thus improving worker safety from the non-use of caustic chemicals.
  • Eliminated secondary waste streams because dry ice is solid CO2, which quickly sublimates and disappears upon contact with the surface being cleaned.

ROI / Cost Justification:

  • Savings of $2,956 per station per week.
  • Labor hours reduced from 7.2 to 0.5 per robot.
  • $153,712 in annual savings over the traditional method of cleaning (for 38 robot cleanings per week).
  • ROI is 344 robot cleanings or 2.3 months.

Compared to hammering and chiseling, Cold Jet's Aero 40 system reduced required labor from four workers to one and cut labor time by up to 69% and cleaning costs by up to 60%, while drastically reducing equipment damage and eliminating chemical solvents and secondary waste streams. Across 38 robot cleanings per week, the switch produced an estimated $153,712 in annual savings with an ROI of about 2.3 months.

More about dry ice blasting equipment for weld line cleaning

Contact

Ready to Get Started?

Contact us today to discover how our dry ice cleaning machines can enhance your process.